Question from Gianfranco Geroldi (in the Glorantha Digest), answer by Greg Stafford. Published 15th Aug 2009.
|Q:||Months ago I had a short but stimulating “conversation” with John Hughes about the nature of perception of Cosmic Sexism in Glorantha. The final question was: are Gods, like Orlanth and Ernalda, really male and female, or is their worshippers’ vision and society that which needs to attribute a sex even to gods and so has (artificially) called them male and female?|
|A:||The key here is what level of recognition, projection and identification we are talking about.We have to look at what we mean by “really male and female.” We have a tendency to equate these with sex and gender, but in fact the sex and gender part are only manifestations, not the root origins.We have to look at what we mean by “really male and female.” We have a tendency to equate these with sex and gender, but in fact the sex and gender part are only manifestations, not the root origins.In the ultimate Divine world male and female do not exist. However, such etheric understanding is just about impossible for mortals to understand due to the finite nature of human beings. This universal descends from on high to be more understandable to humans.At a slightly less universal but nearly as etheric understanding we find a dualism which has no gender or sex, but whose differences are apparently exclusive. Call it This and That. |
These active and passive powers are nearly worthless to human beings in a practical way, and we need to have a more detailed understanding of them to use them, perhaps even to understand them. They manifest in a more perceptible way as a variety of dualistic perceptions. We find the recognizable oppositions of light and dark, of active and passive, and also as everyone’s favorite: male and female.
A god manifests a type of energy which is predominantly “male” when perceived by human beings, a goddess of “female” energy. I will stress that almost all entities consist of mixtures of the two (which are, remember, actually both from the Universal singular that we can’t understand). Another fine definition of this exists in that we can separate “masculine” from male, though our vocabulary starts tripping us up. I am going to consciously (for this argument) separate men from masculine by stating that male and female are the sex part, not the gender part. Men and women have different body parts.
So where on the spectrum of differentiation do Orlanth and Ernalda exist? We know both are connected to the Universal Plane, which means that they have direct access to and/or part of that Universal non gendered and non differentiated state. However, by definition they would not be separate from each other there. They would be one, joined in eternity (much like the state we may obtain at that moment of coital orgasm).
On the plane of This and That they exist separately, but since gender is not present then they are equally non gendered. Both exist, but they are not god and goddess, but a kind of pure deity. Are they Orlanth and Ernalda? Well, that depends on the perceptor. Did we get there by refining our understanding and experience with Orlanth? Then it might be Orlanth. How about the level where they have gender? Orlanth is the manifestation of the masculine energy, Ernalda of the feminine. Do they have real sex and gender? I’d not talking here about their ultimate nature, but about their nature as perceivable here. By definition we say they do have gender: Orlanth is masculine and Ernalda is feminine.
Here lies the answer to the question you asked.
Yes, I say, they are male and female.
Are they so entirely subjective that we can change their sex? Not, really. If we start to jiggled their genders and confuse their ultimate nature with their perceptible and accepted (social and experiential) nature then we are just throwing away everything that has been assembled about the Orlanth and Ernalda experience.
What happens if we do jiggle it then? It can be done, I will hear the subjectivists say, “We have only accepted/perceived that Orlanth is predominantly masculine/male, and Ernalda feminine/female.”
Sure, this might be done, and I can cite a bunch of deities where it has been done from terrestrial cultures (mostly tricksters, mind you. Yea yea, don’t tell me about Loki’s accusation that Odin became a woman, etc. We are concerned with the rules, not the exceptions.)
What DOES happen, though, is that we get a feminized version of Orlanth (Nandan), a masculine version of Ernalda (Vinga) or some kind of mixture of the two (Heler.) These, however, are separate entities at the perceivable level where humans interact with them.
- Belintar’s Book: Aldrya’s Own Story (1998)
- Greg Sez Guest: Does the Emperor party or not? (Jan 1999)
- Greg Sez Guest: Dragon Slayers and Dragons of Saird (Feb 1999)
- Greg Sez Guest: EAST ISLES: United or not? (Jan 1999)
- Greg Sez Guest: The Mighty Janube (Nov 1998)
- Greg Sez Guests: Five Troll Questions (Sep 1999)
- Greg Sez: Barbarians – Heortlings, Vingkotlings, and Orlanthi (Jan 1998)
- Greg Sez: Between the Devil and the Dawn Age (Aug 1998)
- Greg Sez: Chaos Taints Q&A (2007)
- Greg Sez: Ducks and Eggs (Dec 1997)
- Greg Sez: How Big Is My God? (Oct 1998)
- Greg Sez: How Does the Red Emperor Rule? (Feb 1999)
- Greg Sez: Humakt Illuminated? (Apr 1998)
- Greg Sez: Information about Elves (Jan 2000)
- Greg Sez: Malkioni Literacy (May 1999)
- Greg Sez: Metals In Prax (Feb 1998)
- Greg Sez: Mistress Race Trolls
- Greg Sez: Second Age Peloria and Carmania (2007)
- Greg Sez: Sheng Seleris in Hell (May 1998)
- Greg Sez: Tada’s High Tumulus (Feb 2000)
- Greg Sez: The Kingdom of War (Jul 1998)
- Greg Sez: The Mother of Monsters (Aug 2009)
- Greg Sez: The Nature of Harmony and Fertility (Jun 1999)
- Greg Sez: The Red Emperor (Sep 1998)
- Greg Sez: The Sky World (Aug 2009)
- Greg Sez: The Southpath Gods (Jul 1999)
- Greg Sez: What is it with the Underworld? (Apr 2007)
- Greg Sez: Who Are the Blue Peoples? (Mar 1998)
- Greg Sez: Who are the Dog Fathers? (May 1999)
- Greg Sez: Who was Baroshi? (Jun 1998)
- Greg Sez: Why do the Giants use the River of Cradles (May 1999)
- Greg Sez: Yelmalio (Mar 2000)
- Library of Londarios: Ancestors of the Lenshi Kings (1998)
- Library of Londarios: Clarifying the Primal Worlds (Feb 2003)
- Library of Londarios: Danmalastan (1999)
- Library of Londarios: Deneskerva the Great Sister
- Library of Londarios: Postcards From Glorantha (Mar 2004)
- Library of Londarios: Stellar FAQ (Dec 1999)
- Library of Londarios: The Abiding Book (1999)
- Library of Londarios: The Birth of Elmal (1993)
- Library of Londarios: The Kings of Seshnela, Part One (1999)
- Library of Londarios: The Kings of Seshnela, Part Three (1999)
- Library of Londarios: The Kings of Seshnela, Part Two (1999)
- Library of Londarios: What the Mystic Taught Me (1998)
- Myth of the Month: Aedin’s Wall (2000)
- Myth of the Month: Chariots and Chariot Gods (2003)
- Myth of the Month: How Orlanth Met Ernalda (1998)
- Myth of the Month: How the Islands Came Apart (1998)
- Myth of the Month: How Vith Pacified the Anti-Gods
- Myth of the Month: Malkioni Otherworld (2001)
- Myth of the Month: Morden Defends the Camp (1999)
- Myth of the Month: Orlanth makes a Ring (1998)
- Myth of the Month: Shang-Hsa (1998)
- Myth of the Month: Shargash the Destroyer (1998)
- Myth of the Month: The Blue Dragon Sshorga (Dec 1999)
- Myth of the Month: The Orogeria Moon (1998)
- Myth of the Month: The Vithelan Creation of the World (1998)