Skip to content
The Well of Daliath
Menu
Menu

Battle Rules

Posted on November 17, 2022

Something I have long been frustrated by is the tendency that RPG battle rules have always been mass combat rules designed to determine the winner of a battle, rather than something player focusing – that tells us what our player characters did and experience in the battle.

IMO, the GM should determine the outcome of the battle. That can be based on the player character actions (“if you can’t hold this position, the battle is lost” or “you need to defeat the enemy hero or the battle is lost”) or not (frex, in Shakespeare’s Henry V, the English have no idea that they have won the battle until it is over). In the Grand Pendragon Campaign, the battles take the latter approach (even telling us what Arthur rolled on his Battle skill!). I personally prefer something a little more interactive with the players – give them a chance to have the spotlight on them (even if you have already decided the results of the battle, it is easy to say that the results are because of the players or despite the players).

What should be the center of the session’s activity is what the players characters do and experience during the battle. Do they spend most of the battle standing in a line dealing with missile weapons and spells? Do they engage in single combat with champions? Do they try to rush an enemy leader or hero? What goes on elsewhere in the battle is usually unknown to the players and they should only learn about it after the battle is over. A great source of inspiration is John Keegan’s “The Face of Battle” but there are plenty of other books that deal with the actual experience of combatants in battle.


So why are RPG battle rules usually little more than thinly disguised skirmish or mass combat rules? I think that is a result of the war gaming roots of the hobby and tie ins to skirmish miniature games. But a battle is much more than a skirmish – and mass combat rules focus on the overall battle rather than the player characters’ experience.

The problem is thinking that what is needed for a TTRPG is a mass combat system. What I think is needed is a Face of Battle system, and then guidelines to the GM.

If you want to play a mass combat system, there are plenty of great war games out there. But that is a different animal entirely.

Jeff Richard

Next
Previous
RQ Battle rules

Sections

  • Search Tips
  • Current RuneQuest Glorantha Publications
  • RuneQuest Glorantha Corrections and Q&A
  • Catalogue
  • References for Glorantha
    • Gloranthan Canon
  • Gloranthan Documents
  • RPG Systems & Versions
  • Gallery
  • Role-playing in Glorantha
  • About This Site
  • Get involved!

Latest Posts

  • Hero Wars / Battle of Heroes

    We all know that the RQG default setting is the …
  • Battle of Heroes Redux

    Here’s an old post of mine that I am linking …
  • Clan Membership

    People can become clan members by birth or join a …
  • Notes on Valind in Dragon Pass

    Valind does not exactly have much of a cult in …
  • A Sense of How Long Ago Things Were

    From time to time I like to dust off this …

Links

  • Chaosium
  • Glorantha on BRP Central
  • RuneQuest on BRP Central
  • RuneQuest Glorantha on MeWe
  • Glorantha Wiki on Fandom
  • Prince of Sartar Webcomic
  • Glorantha G+ Archives on Tapatalk
  • Search mailing list archive

Latest from BRP Central

  • Another question about Zoo in the Right Arm Islands
  • Setting the Scene for the PC Histories
  • If low is bad, is the autofail roll ignored?
  • Gods of Glorantha Series Prices
  • Thoughts on running a Scorpion Man Horde
  • Dragon Pass Sun Dome/Sun County
  • The Sartarite Diet.
  • Are there any volcanoes in Pent or Prax ?
  • Real-world Inspirations
  • List of Personalities in New Pavis and the Rubble?

Popular Tags

2007 Avalon Hill Boldhome Chaosium Chaos pantheon Cult demographics Cults of Runequest (preview) Doraddi pantheon Ernalda Esrolia (homeland) FR G+ post Greg Stafford Guide to Glorantha (preview) Humakt HW Issaries Jar-eel Lunar Empire Lunar Pantheon Magazine Map Maps Michael O’Brien Mongoose Nochet Nomad Gods Oriflam Orlanth Orlanthi pantheon population demographics Prax (homeland) RQ2 RQ3 RQG Sandy Petersen Sartar (homeland) Solar pantheon Spirit Cult Subcult Tales of the Reaching Moon Tatou Troll / Uz pantheon Yelm Yelmalio

Recently added or updated

  • 1659-1881 A Less Reliable Series of Future Dates

  • 1631-1658 The Reign of Argrath, King of Sartar

  • Wyrm’s Footnotes #15 (2012)

  • Sartar Sun Dome

  • Sun Domers

  • RPG Systems & Versions

  • 1625-1630 The Liberation of Sartar

  • First Four Companions

  • Turtle

  • Loon

  • Otter

  • Sea Eagle

  • Furalor

  • Frona

  • Frog Woman

  • Framanthe

  • Fralar

  • Foundchild the Hunter

  • The 48 Old Ones

  • Flintnail

©2023 The Well of Daliath | Design: Newspaperly WordPress Theme