Official Answers by Chaosium
This covers Chapter 6, pages 162-189.
Modifying Skill Rolls (page 163)
It’s probably second nature to experienced gamers but I don’t see anything about how the GM being able to apply arbitrary bonuses/penalties given circumstances? (like some bonus to Track because it rained recently and the ground is soft, or something) There’s a paragraph on p163, just under “Modifying Skill Rolls“, that probably addresses this, but it’s unclear since it can be read merely as an introduction to the augment rules. More importantly, it doesn’t give any hint as to what a proper range for those bonuses/penalties might be (should the Track example above be 10% or 40%?).
It’s intended that the guidelines for augmenting abilities with Passions/Runes/other skills provide guidance for such benefits, but that regretfully isn’t clear.
Given that there’s a lot of grey area in how much a particular circumstance might truly influence a task, it could be anywhere from ±5 to ±75%. I personally tend to believe that if a modifier is less than ±20% it’s not worth applying, as the difference is something that should be taken into account with the adventurer’s facility with the ability.
Skill Descriptions (page 164)
Second paragraph, “(Elder Race) Lore or (Homeland) Lore” replaced with “Elder Race Lore (Type) or Homeland Lore (Area)”. Later is same paragraph “(Elder Race) Lore” is replaced with “Elder Race Lore (Type)”. (Part of Second printing corrections)
Are there whip rules? I could not find any in the RQ:G book.
The whip that is mentioned in the core rules is for a chariot driver. These whips aren’t really combat weapons (you crack the whip to make noise, not strike the horse).
So it’s a skill to make a cracking sound?
…you crack the whip to make noise, not strike the horse). Quote
To generate an augment to Drive (Chariot)?
Yes or depending on the situation, Intimidate or other applicable roleplaying situations.
Agility Skills (page 164)
Boat (page 164) & Shiphandling (page 182)
Boat provides the adventurer with a skill in handling oared or poled small boats such as rafts, canoes, and rowboats. Boat is primarily a physical activity, unlike Shiphandling, which is knowledge based.
Shiphandling allows an adventurer to successfully command a ship that needs a crew of more than two. For smaller vessels, use the Boat skill (page 164).
What about canoes/rafts suitable for seafaring that can be sailed double handed?
Canoes, rafts, kayaks, and smaller sea-craft all fall under Boat.
The currently-in-development RuneQuest Gamemaster Sourcebook includes rules for sea travel and combat, and identifies which skill goes with which vessel.
Jumping (page 166)
Not quite sure I got the difference between the falling with a normal success vs a special success (and this part doesn’t seem to be covered in the section on Falling, so I can’t easily verify this). The way the phrasing read to me initially was that, if I was supposed to roll 4D6 damage, I only roll 3D6 damage instead (reducing the damage by a “step”) and get to pick a hit location. But on a special success I roll my 4D6 damage, but then roll 1D6 and deduct the result from the damage rolled (and get to pick a hit location)? But I was sure that can be right, because it would actually make rolling a special worse than rolling a normal success.
Mechanically, picking what hit location gets hit in a fall is hugely better than reducing damage by 1D6. It determines whether you break an arm vs being knocked unconscious or dying (if head is rolled).
So I am guessing what it really means is, if you get a success, either normal or special, you roll one less D6 than you would have (rather than actually subtracting the result of a 1D6 roll), meaning that for falling, it doesn’t really make a difference if you had a normal or special success, and that for a crit, you not only roll one D6 less, you also then halve whatever damage is left over. Is that interpretation correct?
Ride (page 166)
Training Riding Animals
Page 167 says that mounts must be trained separately to; accept a rider, remain calm in battle, fight in battle and increase their three attack skills up to 50% below the trainer’s ride skill. Training to accept a rider is stated to take a week. How long do the other types of training take?
The other types of training takes many months, if not years. This can depend hugely on the culture, the environment, the amount of attention provided, and the facilities. On 2/12/2019 at 1:49 PM, CBDunkerson said:
Also, does a war trained mount immediately get 50% below the trainer’s skill in attacks or does that have to be trained separately (or separately for each attack)?
Those are general guidelines. Assume that when a fully-trained warhorse is purchased it will be trained at those levels. If you for some reason desire more granularity, please ask your gamemaster.
Communication Skills (page 168)
Language Tree picture (page 172)
Shouldn’t the branch of the Hyaloring languages lead to the Grazer and Pentan languages?
Here is Jeff’s original drawing from 2017. It was expanded slightly to include the Praxian languages splitting from from Earthtongue and merging with a strand of Theylan after the Dawn IIRC.
So if the answer seems to be yes, is this going to be corrected in the rulebook?
It’s not an error, the artwork is a representation of some of the information in the drawing. Is for your interest. Later publications may provide more information.
Speak Other Language (page 173)
As an example….A Satarite PC starts with 50% in speaking Heortling, which confers a 1/5 of that value (in this case +10%) chance with Stormspeech. Would the +20% the character would gain from being an initiate of Orlanth stack with that 10%, making it 30%?
Orlanth initiates are specifically taught Stormspeech. The skill base of Speak Stormspeech is 0%.
It is not generally necessary during the adventurer creation process to define starting ability in related languages, but whenever adventurers encounter speakers of languages other than their own, the gamemaster should consult the Language Equivalency table above determine if the adventurers have any basic proficiency.Speak Other Language, page 173
And how would any bonuses to Comunications skills be included ?
A character could gain such a bonus twice, once to the initial Speak Own Language (Heortling) value which would then be taken as one fifth for Speak Other Language (Stormspeech), and then again added to that value.
Don’t add the skill category modifier twice:
Skill base skill + skill experience + skill category modifier = total
Communication skills category modifier +10% in all examples below.
Speak Heortling (50%) + skill experience (0%) + skill category modifier (10) = 60%
Speak Stormspeech (0%) + skill experience (20%) + skill category modifier (10) = 30%
An Orlanth initiate would need to get their Speak Heortling to 100% to reach the same untrained proficiency (100 x 1/5 =20 +10% skill category modifier = 30%)
So using Speak Heortling (50%) speakers know Esrolian at 1/2, and Old Pavic, Tarshite, and Stormspeech at 1/5 of their Speak Heortling ability:
Speak Esrolian (0) + skill experience (1/2 of 50 = 25%) + skill category modifier (+10%) = 35%
Speak Old Pavic (0) + skill experience (1/5 of 50 = 10%) + skill category modifier (+10%) = 20%
Speak Tarshite (0) + skill experience (1/5 of 50 = 10%) + skill category modifier (+10%) = 20%
As they’ve been trained to speak Speak Stormspeech, they can speak all Theyalan languages (such as Esrolian, Old Pavic, and Tarshite) at least 1/10 the skill in Stormspeech, and can Speak Heortling at 1/5 their skill. However their Speak Heortling ability is a better base.
Knowledge Skills (page 175)
Battle (page 176)
Does armor count in Battle-skill result table damages?
No. It’s an abstract of many, many injuries.
How do you guys handle massed combat (army vs army)?
The gamemaster’s guide will have some rules on this. Right now I’d adjudicate it as based on a common-sense look at the circumstances and make some Battle rolls, as appropriate.
So far my idea has been: Roll a battle check, if you fail you take a 1d6 wound to a random location as you were wounded during the battle.
On a success you survive, on a special you gain 1d6 renown on a crit you get 2d6 success.
You could also utilize Pendragon’s mass combat system if you’re eager to use something like that.
But I also want to include battle events in the style of Six ages and KODP where you get a short description and then you decide what skill you want to use t osolve the situation. success is rewarded with more loot or reputation.
not entirely sure where to work those in, maybe a seperate percentile check?
Until the mass combat rules are available, I’d suggest using Battle as the default skill to determine whether you can choose an appropriate skill.
You could make a short list of appropriate skills and roll randomly to see which one is required, while a successful Battle roll lets the player decide the skill to use.
For example, roll 1D4 on:
- Weapon skill (attack if missile only, attack/parry if infantry/cavalry)
- Ride (if cavalry, or attack/parry if infantry)
A successful Battle roll lets the player pick which to roll.
I am also unsure how to do post-battle loot, which should be divvied up based on rank, seniority, prestige etc.
Maybe a Luck roll? (being able to find some nice stuff from battlefield pickings)
Or even Reputation? (more prestigious adventurers get better loot, as reward for their recognized efforts) You could also augment this roll with an appropriate skill that was used in the battle, or something Communication-based, as appropriate.
First Aid (Page 177)
First Aid is applied to each individual wound once, which necessitates keeping track of individual hits/wounds. So a limb with 3 separate hits could have first aid applied 3 times, once for each individual wound.
Blows to the limbs beyond the max x2 damage limit no longer register with the limb, but do however register with Total Hit points.
Is it intended that any further damage to Total Hit points received through subsequent hits to limbs (after x2 max dam limit ), will not be possible to heal with the First Aid skill?
Keep track of the individual injuries, not the hit point totals, and this isn’t a problem.
You can’t heal more HP to a particular wound through First Aid than was inflicted, whether that injury was inflicted to a specific wound or to total hit points.
Lores (page 178)
Celestial Lore (page 178)
Can you navigate with Celestial lore?
Yes, but you’ll be unaware of the condition and configuration of the terrain, and would be unable to do so without a clear view of the stars.
For navigation on land, you would be better served using Survival, and use Boat or Shiphandling for navigating at sea.
Celestial Lore would be better used as an augment for one of those other skills.
Cult Lore (page 179)
Does a character automatically have a 5% base chance in every cult, or
Does the statement “An adventurer must be at least an initiate of a cult to learn the secret lore of the cult” mean that cult lore starts at 0 until initiated?
Yes. Although if the information is relevant to an associate / enemy / related cult then you could use your cult lore, but not for specifics. eg. Using Orlanth cult Lore, an orlanth worshipper may know what generally issaries did on the lightbringers quest, but not their ritual preparations for the quest or the magic words they used in a specific encounter. I would use the Modifying skill rolls (page 163) and reduce the skill level accordingly.
Martial Arts (page 181)
Is Martial Arts treated like a weapon for special and critical success purposes? That is, does a critical Martial Arts roll do max damage and bypass armor?
You don’t roll Martial Arts. It’s a threshold.
If you have a Martial Arts skill of 30% and, say, Fist 75%, any roll of Fist equaling 01-30 triggers the benefits of Martial Arts, and any roll of 31-75 is just a normal Fist attack.
If your original attack roll is a special/crit AND it is below your Martial Arts skill, then you apply the benefits of the Martial Arts skill (double damage, normal damage bonus).
Similarly, anyone can parry with a limb, but if the Parry roll is less than the Martial Arts skill, then it blocks 6 points of damage.
Read/Write (all) (page 181)
The sidebar refers to, for example, Read/Write Theyalan, with the Theyalan scripts being common to Esrolian, Heortling, and Tarshite.
In addition to the box, all three are described in the Guide to Glorantha:
All Theyalan languages are written using the Three Sacred Scripts of Lhankor Mhy. These scripts were created by Lhankor Mhy in the God Time and are the same in all Orlanthi lands.
Murnulvretan. Also called “Cat Scratching,” this flowing and ornate semi-syllabary is used primarily by the Orlanthi of Dragon Pass, Holy Country, and East Ralios.
Kanvulvretan. Also called “Dog Scratching,” this syllabary consists of distinct characters (unlike the flowing script of Murnulvretan) marked by angular shapes. It is used primarily by the Orlanthi of Peloria, Fronela, and Ralios.
Both Kanvulvretan and Murnulvretan use the common vocabulary that more or less reproduces most Orlanthi sounds.
Elasa Secrets. Also called “stone scratching,” this script is extremely difficult to learn, and is used only for magical formulae. This script uses the second vocabulary, whose words change in meaning according to a complex code system that must be learned separately.Guide to Glorantha, page 36
If an Esrolian speaking scribe writes a text, can a Heortling speaking scribe read it with no penalties (say both have 75% “read/write Theyalan”)? Without invoking a Translate spell.
Magic Skills (page 182)
Sense Chaos (page 183)
Last paragraph “visible spirits” changed to “invisible spirits”. (Part of Second printing corrections)
Worship (deity) (page 184)
Can an initiate perform a Worship ritual?
All initiates have the worship (their deity) skill. It takes a day to perform and costs initiates 2mps to perform, and must be done at a sacred or sanctified place. See page 184.
rather than Worship being a function reserved for priests?
If you imagine a priest as a master of ceremonies or ritual choreographer, they allow for more complex ceremonies, reenactions, ritual preparations or heroquests. Worship is personal, ritual is communal.
So can an initiate worship on his own, say if he is alone on a desert island?
Yes, providing there is a sacred or sanctified place.
Can an initiate lead a Worship ritual? If ten initiates are without a priest can one of them step up, or not?
Yes and the likely the most experienced would likely be expected to. An excellent role playing opportunity. They would not receive any of the benefits that a priest would though.
Manipulation Skills (page 185)
Conceal (page 185)
It says “A special or critical result adjusts for the SIZ of the item.” I am not sure what that means. Is that referring to the previous line that says that you spend about one melee round per Point of SIZ, meaning if you roll a special or crit, you spend less time concealing the object, which is as if the object had a smaller SIZ?
Craft (specific craft) (page 185)
Is Craft (Bronze) a separate skill to Craft (Iron)?
Yes – different properties. 2 hours ago, Arcadiagt5 said:
I’ve also seen mentions that only Humakt cultists can learn Craft (Iron), is that correct?
Yes. 2 hours ago, Arcadiagt5 said:
Especially given that Babeester Gor, [snip], Lhankor Mhy, Orlanth, Storm Bull all know Enchant Iron?
Enchant yes, craft no.
Are there net rules? I could not find any in the RQ:G book.
No, these are the basic rules, edited down:
NET FIGHTING (MANIPULATION 05%)
Only specially made combat nets are used in battle.
Normal net (05%) ENC 2, STR 15, SR2 (snap 1D4 or ensnare)
Large net (05%) ENC 3, STR 20, SR1 (snap 1D4 or ensnare)
Fighters normally carry nets on the left arm, and in that position the net can be used as a shield. In absorbing blows from edged weapons, its hit points will be destroyed just as would be a regular weapon’s.
Attacking to Ensnare: A successful attack which is not parried allows the attacker a roll on a special hit location table.
01-10 legs caught, cannot move, arms, upper torso, and head are free.
11-12 arms caught; legs and head are free.
13-15 right arm and head caught.
16-18 left arm and head caught.
19-20 head caught, vision obscured, attack/parry halved.
The areas caught must be freed by ripping, cutting, or burning. If there is no tension on the net, the victim can simply unwind the net from himself. A D100 roll equal to or less than the victim’s DEX as a percentage will accomplish the unwinding. Make the roll once per melee round. If the character’s armed are pinned, he cannot unwind without help.
Defending Against Nets: A net may be parried. The shield used to parry a net is caught in the net, immobilizing the shield arm, unless the parrier rolls their DEX or less on D100. A weapon used to parry a net will be caught unless the parrying character makes a roll of DEX times 5 or less on D100. If the attacker’s weapon is caught in the net, it immobilizes their weapon arm unless they let go of the weapon.Cults of Glorantha book, forthcoming
Can a net not be thrown to tangle someone?
Attacking to ensnare = tangling someone by throwing your net at them. However:
If there is no tension on the net, the victim can simply unwind the net from himself.
So you don’t let go.
- CHA4028 RuneQuest: Roleplaying in Glorantha – Chapter 01 Introduction Q&A
- CHA4028 RuneQuest: Roleplaying in Glorantha – Chapter 02 Glorantha Q&A
- CHA4028 RuneQuest: Roleplaying in Glorantha – Chapter 03 Adventurers Q&A
- CHA4028 RuneQuest: Roleplaying in Glorantha – Chapter 03 Pregenerated Adventurers Q&A
- CHA4028 RuneQuest: Roleplaying in Glorantha – Chapter 04 Homelands Q&A
- CHA4028 RuneQuest: Roleplaying in Glorantha – Chapter 05 Game System Q&A
- CHA4028 RuneQuest: Roleplaying in Glorantha – Chapter 07 Combat Q&A pages 191-206
- CHA4028 RuneQuest: Roleplaying in Glorantha – Chapter 07 Combat Q&A pages 206-225
- CHA4028 RuneQuest: Roleplaying in Glorantha – Chapter 08 Runes Q&A
- CHA4028 RuneQuest: Roleplaying in Glorantha – Chapter 09 Passions & Reputation Q&A
- CHA4028 RuneQuest: Roleplaying in Glorantha – Chapter 10 Magic Q&A
- CHA4028 RuneQuest: Roleplaying in Glorantha – Chapter 11 Spirit Magic Q&A
- CHA4028 RuneQuest: Roleplaying in Glorantha – Chapter 11 Spirit Magic Spells Q&A
- CHA4028 RuneQuest: Roleplaying in Glorantha – Chapter 12 Rune Cults Q&A
- CHA4028 RuneQuest: Roleplaying in Glorantha – Chapter 12 Rune Cults The Cults Q&A
- CHA4028 RuneQuest: Roleplaying in Glorantha – Chapter 13 Rune Magic Q&A
- CHA4028 RuneQuest: Roleplaying in Glorantha – Chapter 13 Rune Magic Spells Q&A
- CHA4028 RuneQuest: Roleplaying in Glorantha – Chapter 14 Shamans Q&A
- CHA4028 RuneQuest: Roleplaying in Glorantha – Chapter 15 Spirits & the Spirit World Q&A
- CHA4028 RuneQuest: Roleplaying in Glorantha – Chapter 16 Sorcery Q&A
- CHA4028 RuneQuest: Roleplaying in Glorantha – Chapter 16 Sorcery Spells Q&A
- CHA4028 RuneQuest: Roleplaying in Glorantha – Chapter 17 Equipment & Wealth Q&A
- CHA4028 RuneQuest: Roleplaying in Glorantha – Chapter 18 Between Adventures Q&A
- CHA4028 RuneQuest: Roleplaying in Glorantha – Chapter 19 Adventurer Sheets Q&A
- CHA4028 RuneQuest: Roleplaying in Glorantha – Chapter 20 Conversion Guide